OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY
11230 STATE ROUTE 364, St Marys, OH 45885
Based on 2026 CMS Data
Official Government Ratings
Health Inspections
Frequency & severity of deficiencies
Staffing Levels
Nurse hours per resident per day
Quality Measures
Clinical outcomes & care quality
Resident & Family Councils Active
Active councils indicate resident empowerment and facility transparency.
Vetting This Facility? Get Answers They Don't Volunteer
Free guide: the exact questions to ask OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY, how to pull the public records (ownership, inspections, penalties), and how to request the info that isn't online — like the medical director.
Check your inbox!
Your facility vetting guide is on its way.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Care Quality Indicators
Lower is better
Lower is better
Lower is better
Lower is better
How OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY Compares
OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY is a 53-bed for-profit nursing facility in St Marys, Ohio. It holds an overall CMS rating of 4 out of 5 stars, above the Ohio average of 3.2 stars. Its strongest area is health inspections, rated 4 stars. Its rate of high-risk residents with pressure ulcers (5.2%) is above the Ohio average of 3.4% — a measure worth asking the staff about. With 53 certified beds, it operates near capacity at roughly 94% occupied.
Among the 3 nursing facilities ElderVoice tracks in St Marys, 1 hold a 5-star rating and the local average is 4.0 stars.
By the numbers vs. Ohio average
- Long-stay antipsychotic medication use: 8.5% — better than the Ohio average of 8.8%.
- Falls with major injury: 1.5% — better than the Ohio average of 3.2% (54% lower).
- High-risk pressure ulcers: 5.2% — worse than the Ohio average of 3.4% (55% higher).
- Short-stay rehospitalization: 23.2% — better than the Ohio average of 24.9%.
Comparisons use CMS Care Compare data (updated September 9, 2026) measured against Ohio averages across 922 facilities tracked by ElderVoice.
Questions to Ask OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY
Use these facility-specific questions when calling admissions, touring the building, or comparing OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY with other nursing homes in St Marys.
What keeps OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY's health inspections rating strong?
This category is rated 4 out of 5 stars. Ask for concrete staffing, training, or care-process examples behind the score.
What practices help OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY keep falls with major injury below the state average?
Falls with major injury is 1.5% here versus 3.2% across Ohio. Lower is generally better for this CMS measure.
What is OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY doing to reduce high-risk pressure ulcers?
High-risk pressure ulcers is 5.2% here versus 3.4% across Ohio. Lower is generally better for this CMS measure.
How does OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY maintain staffing when occupancy is high?
The facility reports roughly 94% occupancy across 53 certified beds, so ask how staffing is adjusted during full census periods.
How can a new family connect with existing councils at OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY?
Active resident or family councils can provide useful context about daily life, responsiveness, and recurring concerns.
What would the first 30 days look like for a new resident at OTTERBEIN ST MARYS RETIREMENT COMMUNITY?
Ask who builds the care plan, how medication changes are communicated, how often families receive updates, and who to call after hours.
The Senior Community Around St Marys
St Marys sits in Auglaize County, where adults 65 and older make up about 18.3% of the population — a share of seniors in line with Ohio as a whole (17.0% statewide). The area's median household income is higher than the state average, reflecting a higher cost of living.
- Residents 65+
- 8,346 (18.3%)
- Median age
- 40.4 years
- Median household income
- $66,193
- Median home value
- $146,400
Demographics for Auglaize County from the U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey (ACS) 5-year estimates. Provided as local context for families comparing care options near St Marys.
Facility Details
Other Facilities in St Marys
Give Them a Daily Friend
Our AI companion calls your loved one daily for friendly conversation and wellness check-ins. We detect mood changes and alert you if something seems off.
- AI calls them daily
- Friendly conversation
- Alerts if something's wrong
Works on any phone. No app needed.