OUR LADY OF CONSOLATION NURSING AND REHAB CARE CTR

Official Government Ratings

Care Quality Indicators

How OUR LADY OF CONSOLATION NURSING AND REHAB CARE CTR Compares

OUR LADY OF CONSOLATION NURSING AND REHAB CARE CTR is a 450-bed nonprofit nursing facility in West Islip, New York. It holds an overall CMS rating of 2 out of 5 stars, below the New York average of 3.1 stars. Its strongest area is staffing (4 stars), while health inspections (2 stars) is its weakest. Its rate of falls resulting in major injury (1.3%) is below the New York average of 3.1%, a favorable sign for resident care. With 450 certified beds, it has notable available capacity at roughly 62% occupied.

By the numbers vs. New York average

• Long-stay antipsychotic medication use: 16.0% — worse than the New York average of 13.8%.
• Falls with major injury: 1.3% — better than the New York average of 3.1% (57% lower).
• High-risk pressure ulcers: 3.0% — better than the New York average of 6.8% (56% lower).
• Short-stay rehospitalization: 22.6% — worse than the New York average of 20.7%.

Comparisons use CMS Care Compare data (updated May 4, 2026) measured against New York averages across 596 facilities tracked by ElderVoice.

The Senior Community Around West Islip

West Islip sits in Suffolk County, where adults 65 and older make up about 16.9% of the population — a share of seniors in line with New York as a whole (16.5% statewide). The area's median household income is higher than the state average, reflecting a higher cost of living.

Residents 65+

250,684 (16.9%)

Median age

41.7 years

Median household income

$105,362

Median home value

$413,900

Demographics for Suffolk County from the U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey (ACS) 5-year estimates. Provided as local context for families comparing care options near West Islip.

Facility Details